I visited a school a couple of weeks ago and they were obviously having a bit of a clear out – there was a skip at the side of the school full of rubbish and on top I was surprised to see some whiteboards…nothing wrong with them just surplus to requirements! I have to say I was tempted to ask for one!
With the almost total fitting of Smart boards of every type and brand in classrooms it seems that the days of the whiteboard are numbered – well they certainly were in this school! But is it really progress to get rid of them altogether or do they still have a place in our classrooms?
I like a whiteboard – there I have said it….no I really do, and I am not convinced that removing them from classrooms is a good thing. So let me explain my argument –
Now I am not saying that I dislike smart boards (for want of a generic name) – I understand their versatility and all the exciting options that they bring. But they do bring with them some disadvantages and limitations and I am never too sure about the health aspects of large TV screens being on all day! ( I have written about this in another article – linked below)
http://pp.distractweb.co.uk/2016/11/18/class-screens-what-do-we-see-in-them/
However lets consider some of the advantages of whiteboards and why I like having one in a classroom.
- The first thing is that they are always available – by this I mean that they never malfunction (unless you run out of pens!) There is never a problem with connections or start up woes or out of line screen positions or the whole host of things that can happen on the smartboard or computer. How many times have you started a lesson and then moved on to the smart board only for it to freeze or not work….and the lesson grinds to a halt! NEVER happens with a whiteboard!
- It is easy to use – there are no programs to run or connections to have – you don’t have to switch to another screen so that a child can come and write something. Simply give the pen to the child and ask them to do ….whatever.
- Whiteboards are often bigger than the interactive smartboards – so giving plenty of room to incorporate ideas, pictures, children’s input …whatever it may be!
- You can use them at a moments notice – they don’t need to be set up or programmed or anything…at any point in a lesson you can just grab a pen and write or draw something instantly
- What you write stays on there – this for me is an important point. Because they are not switchable, whatever you write stays. So if you need to have a reminder for your children about something that is happening next week or for the test on Friday then it stays in view all the time. If you run a behaviour management strategy that incorporates names on the board and ticks etc then it goes up there and stays up there. If you want to run a carousel of activities for a morning then they can be written up on the board and they will be there for everyone to see.
- Children can use it with ease – if you have some activities which require pupils to explain or illustrate things…lets say for a presentation exercise or speaking and listening then they will be able to do drawings and writing on the board for others to use in the activity.
- You can leave personal reminders to yourself about events coming up or things you have to do or organise. In a busy day it’s easy to forget things so in this way they are always visible to remind you.
As you can no doubt tell by now, I like having a whiteboard in my classroom – I certainly always had a whiteboard in my HT’s office and I even have a whiteboard in my kitchen at home!
But in saying this about whiteboards does not mean I am not in favour of smart boards in classrooms. In fact quite the opposite. The inclusion of these type of boards brings with it new and exciting elements and experiences to the education of the children and allows teachers to use the vast array of resources available both from the internet and also specific to the technology itself.
But and it’s a big but – in my opinion it is a mistake to replace whiteboards with the new smart boards. There is a definite place in the classroom for both these resources and it should not be a choice of one at the expense of the other.
Many schools are now starting to realise this and I know of 3 schools who have bought new whiteboards to replace those they had previously removed.
With a bit of careful planning and rearrangement both can be productively used in both extending and consolidating the classroom learning experience.